Print Friendly and PDF

Vitamin D2 vs D3: Which One Do I Want?

Elizabeth Renter
by
January 13th, 2013
Updated 07/07/2014 at 8:26 pm
Pin It

sunrises4 265x165 Vitamin D2 vs D3: Which One Do I Want?The best way to get the “sunshine vitamin” is by getting some sunshine. (No shocker there.) But, in the winter, getting a healthy dose of vitamin D each day can be more difficult. For this reason, many people turn to supplements. But, which vitamin D supplement is best, and can’t you just up your intake of “enriched” foods like milk and cereals? Vitamin D2 vs D3: which will conquer?

Vitamin D2 vs D3

Looking on your milk carton or your box of cereal, you will find vitamin D inside. It’s fortified to include this crucial nutrient. But, not all vitamin D is created equal.

There are two main types of vitamin D precursors. One is cholecalciferol (D3) and the other is ergocalciferol (D2). Both are transformed by the body into useable vitamin D or 25(OH)D. But, there are differences. D2 is what you’ll find in fortified food, and scientists are saying this form simply isn’t as good as D3, which is generated by the sun and naturally produced in our bodies.

According to a study in the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism, D3 is 87% more potent than D2.

Another, more recent study found that when supplementing with 1,000 IU of D3 or D2, during winter months, D3 maintained 25(OH)D levels where D2 did not. As a matter of fact, supplementing with the same amount of D2 was related to a decrease in the amount of 25(OH)D.

“Overall, total serum 25(OH)D concentrations were 21 nmol/l lower in participants receiving D2 compared with those receiving D3, among whom total serum 25(OH)D concentrations remained unchanged,” said the researchers.

“These findings contribute to the accumulating evidence that vitamin D3 and vitamin D2 have different pharmacokinetic profiles for serum 25(OH)D.”

Put simply—your body doesn’t recognize these two forms of vitamin D precursor in the same way. Put even more simply: Your body prefers vitamin D3.

But that isn’t all you need to know concerning the fight: vitamin D2 vs D3. One meta-analysis by the Cochrane Database examined how two different groups reacted to vitamin D supplementation: one group taking D2 and the other D3. Specifically, they looked at mortality rates for people who supplemented their diets with the vitamins.

The analysis included 94,000 individuals, all coming from a total of 50 randomized controlled trials. The analysis found:

  • A 6% relative risk reduction among those who used vitamin D3
  • A 2% relative risk increase among those who used D2

In an article posted on Live in the Now, Dr. John J. Cannell writes:

“Amazingly, this study somehow slipped under the radar…

You would think a paper that took a look at tens of thousands of subjects and analyzed the efficacy of prescription vitamin D (D2) and over-the-counter vitamin D (D3) would warrant a news story or two.

To my knowledge, these papers are the first to paint such a clear picture about the efficacy between D3 and D2.”

The Importance of Vitamin D

Vitamin D is important, to put it mildly. And many people are deficient. Vitamin D deficiency has been linked to injuries, Alzheimer’s disease,  psoriasis, diabetes, kidney disease, periodontal disease, cardiovascular disease, and even schizophrenia and depression.

On the other side of things, optimum vitamin D levels has been shown to positively impact a number of health conditions. Vitamin D can help:

In the winter, when your body requires more time outdoors for the same level of vitamin D, you may be tempted to supplement. If you do, choose vitamin D3, and stay away from D2. For more information on attaining vitamin D, check out these 7 awesome natural sources of vitamin D.

Additional Sources:

Examiner.com

ScienceNewsLine

Cambridge Journal – British Journal of Nutrition

From around the web:

  • http://pymealmundo.com/edu/user/view.php?id=19665&course=1 aaa car insurance calculator

    When used to help fat loss, reinforcement could be a valuable tool,
    but at the end of the day if it isn’t accompanied by other tries to lose pounds, you are presumably not going to get very far. For starters, RGB offers a much wider range of colors than CMYK does, and RGB colors tend to be more vivid than CMYK. If you have a classic Corvette restoration project that is languishing because you insist that it be done right and with zero tolerance for substandard work, then call a professional now for a free, confidential consultation about your project, how much it will cost and how long it will take to complete.

  • http://www.thebritishcbtcounsellingservice.com/ Eric Carter

    Wow – that's a long list of diseases and conditions linked to one vitamin. Guess those are more than enough reasons to make sure to maintain a healthy diet and take supplements when needed.

  • commodore

    None of this makes the "news." WHY IS THAT? THINK VERY CAREFULLY ABOUT THAT. Yes, it is government controlled and they make Big money off of cancer drugs and they don't want you to know this!
    But besides that there has to be coordination. Think about the APA and newspaper "editors." They are coordinating to foist a hidden agenda, not just to not offend advertisers, but to push a message, mind-control if you will. Just be aware of this stuff! Doing that alone defeats them.