24 Comments

  1. I don’t consider those names you mentioned quacks, of the ones I have heard of you listed. It does not take a rocket scientist to know about GMOs. As a person who grew up on a farm and still has a farm, I loudly oppose GMO anything. Right now you enjoy eating food cheaply and have a choice. If they continue it will be expensive and limited. I do not believe they should be labeled, I believe GMOs should not be allowed.

    1. Canadian_Skeptic says:

      “It does not take a rocket scientist to know about GMOs”
      >>You’re right. It takes a molecular biologist. Rocket scientists don’t know jack about GMOs. And yes, it does take a significant degree of education to understand GMOs. That’s why lay people so frequently get the facts wrong. It’s a very complicated and technically challenging subject.
      “As a person who grew up on a farm and still has a farm, I loudly oppose GMO anything.”
      >>Good for you. You almost certainly know far more about farming than me. But I doubt you can explain alternative splicing of pre-mRNAs and how that can relate to the transgene constructs used in GMOs. Have a little humility and admit your limitations.
      “I believe GMOs should not be allowed”
      >>A lot of diabetics would disagree with you. Did you know a significant amount, if not the majority, of insulin comes from GM bacteria? Probably not.

  2. health _concious says:

    Dear Canadian Septic, I would suggest you put your credentials down, so others may understand you better, and may you not judge people because you do not agree with them wanting wholesome natural foods in their bodies.. Its a planet of free choice and if those that sign against GMO, choose to, irrespective of their knowledge, honour them in their free choice. I through my own choice eat as much wholesome organic food ( which is natural food in case you dont know) and I stay away from those GMO’s My health is good. How about yours? We DO NOT want companies like Monsanto by free market choice. Please do some research on GMO,,,,if you choose to, and then the lights may go on in your Head. Whatever your choice, you are honoured

    1. Viriato77 says:

      Here’s the problem with your assertions of opinions and free choice. You can chose your opinion not your own facts and you can make your own choices as long as they don’t impinge on the choices of others.
      “Anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that ‘my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.’” -Isaac Asimov

  3. Viriato77 says:

    How does 15 pages of 300 signatures each equates to ’59 million’ signatures…Does not math

    1. Logically you are against yourself!!!

    2. Rebel Writer says:

      Not all signatories represent one person – for example, The California Certified Organic Farmers is obviously more than just ONE farmer – it represents a whole group of people. There are several signatories on the list that are for a GROUP of people, that is why ONE LISTING does not always equal ONE signature. The Letter to America site explains this very clearly.

      1. hyperzombie says:

        The California Certified Organic Farmers is obviously more than just ONE farmer
        Did they ask these farmers if they supported the petition? How many of them grow GMOs and Organic crops?

        1. JibbaJabbaJake says:

          Oh my god. Did they actually count all the members of organizations that signed on…as a blanket rule without polling each individual?

  4. “There is no independent research which our agencies will accept.” So, you’ve taken your anti-GMO stance and will refuse to even consider any research/evidence whose conclusions you dislike? Interesting that anti-GMO has become a religion now, i suspect the paperwork for tax exempt status is in the works already?

    1. Rebel Writer says:

      I started writing about GMOs over four years ago FOR NOTHING. Not a penny. That and many other things that most people have given me grief about. I won’t be silenced and it has nothing to do with money. It is part of my responsibility to share what I know with the world. They can take it or leave it – you too , Eric. I hope you don’t perish prematurely due to your ignorance is all, but then again you might be hired to refute articles like this – I never can tell a shill from someone with their ostrich head in the ground – so good luck either way. Karma’s a %#!^#*@#^ as they say. And no religion is usually based on dogma accepted as truth without questioning. I QUESTION everything.

  5. Dan Boersma says:

    The author of this, Christina Sarich, Is a liar. She claims 59 million people have signed the letter, yet the article clearly states that people who “represent” 60 million people have signed it.
    She then tries to disguise the lie by making the number “59,742,753”, which she cannot possibly know, so it looks like that is the actual figure. Want to know what it’s like to lie for a living? Ask Christina Sarich.

    1. Rebel Writer says:

      Nice try Dan – unless you count an entire group of farmers as one person, one signatory. As I stated above, not all signatories represent one person – for example, The California
      Certified Organic Farmers is obviously more than just ONE farmer – it
      represents a whole group of people. There are several signatories on the
      list that are for a GROUP or people.The letter outlines this very clearly if you click on the links. There is no lie in the article, but a deep misrepresentation of the author in your statement.

      1. Dan Boersma says:

        Thanks for responding , Christina.
        The title says “signatures”. 59 million people did not sign this. You are now spinning your own lie.

      2. Dan Boersma says:

        The funny thing is, I knew it was you before clicking the profile on your name. The only person that would even try to defend such an obvious misrepresentation is the liar herself.
        Nice try hiding behind a pseudonym to make it seem like there is at least one other person in the world who can’t see that you are lying.

        1. Rebel Writer says:

          NO hiding – anyone can click on my Discus pseudonym or find me on Facebook, Google Plus, etc. I stand behind what I said. It is you who misrepresents; however, it doesn’t matter if there was 1 signature or millions – people don’t want GMOs. Try arguing against that, my friend.

    2. Rebel Writer says:

      You are mincing words. An orange is indeed different than a nectarine, but give me a freaking break. What about GMOs should people be excited or ‘for’ instead of ‘against.’ Arguing about the language chosen to represent masses of people who are sick of being poisoned is a tactic to sway the conversation from the real issues. Disease, Environmental degradation, the fact that GMOs are banned all over the word due to concerns about their safety and the absolute lack of risk assessment done by governments who have allowed them. Comment on any one of those issues if you dare.

      1. Dan Boersma says:

        This is exhibit A on why you should stick to your fancy stretching classes and leave agricultural issues to, you know, farmers and the scientists who support them.
        1. Genetic engineering is a breeding technique, like radiation breeding or crossbreeding. It’s simply a way to alter DNA to express desired protein(s). There is zero reputable evidence that GE foods contribute to dieasese, in fact BT corn helps prevent a fungus from forming in corn, a fungus which causes birth defects in babies.
        2. “Environmental degradation”. Name any form of environmental degradation that is caused by genetically engineered crops.
        3. “Banned all over the world”
        Seriously, learn something. GE crops are banned in exactly one country on Earth.
        I will continue if and when I see that you’ve made an effort to learn something.

  6. Rebel Writer says:

    The typical means of any shill – discredit someone as a ‘non-expert’ without defending their actual arguments – but nonetheless, there are many ‘experts’ on the signatory list. FYI – You don’t have to be a biotech scientist to understand that GMOs can be dangerous, the same way you don’t have to be a doctor to know if you are catching a cold.

  7. Bret Davis says:

    LAYS and FRITO LAYS chip dip All are made with Go’s and also many popular drinks. Even those small square looking pretzels that have peanut butter in them are GMO.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *